What the value of an historic Roman nail teaches us about worth


Fifty miles north of what’s now Edinburgh and practically 2,000 years in the past, the Roman empire’s Twentieth Legion started to construct a fort close to the River Tay. By Roman requirements, it was unremarkable, regardless of its 20-hectare measurement and earthworks a number of metres thick. It boasted a forge, hospital and granaries, however lacked baths and aqueducts — maybe as a result of it was deserted just some years after development began, because the Romans started to drag out of Scotland. They left behind a curious treasure: 10 tons of nails, practically 1,000,000 of the issues.

The nail hoard was found in 1960 in a four-metre-deep pit coated by two metres of gravel. The outer nails had rusted right into a protecting shell, leaving the interior nails in good situation. There have been so many who archaeologists have been considerably at a loss as to what to do with all of them. Most of the nails have been offered off as souvenirs to assist fund the excavation, some as units of 5 in commemorative containers. It appears a bit disrespectful in the present day, however as the top of the dig, Sir Ian Richmond, commented, “Even when a set have been despatched to each museum on earth there would nonetheless be many tons left over.”

Why had the Romans buried 1,000,000 nails? The doubtless clarification is that the withdrawal was rushed, they usually didn’t need the native Caledonians getting their arms on 10 tons of weapon-grade iron. The Romans buried the nails so deep that they’d not be found for nearly two millennia.

Later civilisations would worth the expert blacksmith’s labour in a nail much more than the uncooked materials. As Roma Agrawal explains in her new pleasant ebook Nuts and Bolts, early Seventeenth-century Virginians would typically burn down their properties in the event that they have been planning to relocate. This was an try and get better the precious nails, which could possibly be reused after sifting the ashes. The concept one may burn down a complete home simply to reclaim the nails underlines how scarce, pricey and beneficial the simple-seeming expertise was.

The excessive worth of nails on the time was partly as a result of Britain had banned the export of treasured nails to its colonies. The arguments about industrial coverage and nationwide safety that now rage over silicon-chip-fabrication expertise have been related to the nail-making commerce 4 centuries in the past.

That each one appears unusual in the present day, when nails are so low-cost that few folks even assume to surprise how they acquired that manner. The economist Daniel Sichel asks that query in a analysis paper printed a few years in the past, drawing on information starting from the 18th-century accounts of Greenwich Hospital to wholesale nail costs in Nineteenth-century Philadelphia.

His headline discovering is that the actual worth of nails was broadly unchanged by way of the 18th century, fell by 90 per cent between the late 1700s and mid-1900s, and has been rising ever since, partly due to the price of uncooked supplies, and maybe as a result of trendy nails are extra complicated and customised than they was. And as Sichel factors out, the value of “put in nails” stays extremely low-cost, because of the invention of the nail gun.

Why did costs fall a lot after the late 1700s? One clarification comes from a foundational textual content of economics, Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations, which described the massive productiveness of a then-modern pin manufacturing unit, because of the specialisation of the manufacturing course of. “One man attracts out the wire, one other straights it, a 3rd cuts it, a fourth factors it, a fifth grinds it on the prime for receiving the top”. This manufacturing course of was tons of of instances extra environment friendly than one particular person working alone.

Whether or not Smith himself had actually seen such a manufacturing unit is now a controversial query, however the underlying level will not be. The division of labour and the rising automation of the method delivered cheaper pins and, little question, cheaper nails too. Sichel agrees: though the falling worth of nails was pushed partly by cheaper iron and cheaper power, many of the credit score goes to nail producers who merely discovered extra environment friendly methods to show metal into nails.

Nails themselves have modified over time, however Sichel studied them as a result of they haven’t modified a lot. Roman lamps and Roman chariots are very completely different from LED strips and sports activities vehicles, however Roman nails are nonetheless clearly nails. It will be absurd to attempt to monitor the altering worth of sports activities vehicles since 1695, however to ask the identical query of nails makes good sense.

As Agrawal’s ebook explains, there may be an limitless fascination in on a regular basis objects comparable to springs, wheels and nails, from the physics behind them to easy sensible ideas. (I didn’t know, till I learn the ebook, that nails typically bend not as a result of I whack them too laborious however as a result of I don’t whack them laborious sufficient.)

I make no apology for being obsessed by a selected function of those objects: their worth. I’m an economist, in any case. After writing two books in regards to the historical past of innovations, one factor I’ve learnt is that whereas it’s the enchantingly refined applied sciences that get all of the hype, it’s a budget applied sciences that change the world. The Gutenberg printing press remodeled civilisation not by altering the character of writing however by altering its value — and it might have achieved little with no parallel collapse within the worth of surfaces to jot down on, because of an often-overlooked expertise known as paper. Photo voltaic panels had just a few area of interest makes use of till they turned low-cost; now they’re remodeling the worldwide power system.

A Roman nail and a contemporary nail have an identical kind, however a radically completely different worth. That alone is why one was a carefully guarded treasure and the opposite is a disposable puncture hazard.

Written for and first printed within the Monetary Instances on 16 June 2023.

The paperback of “The Subsequent 50 Issues That Made The Fashionable Economic system” is now out within the UK.

“Endlessly insightful and filled with surprises — precisely what you’d count on from Tim Harford.”- Invoice Bryson

“Witty, informative and endlessly entertaining, that is common economics at its most participating.”- The Each day Mail

I’ve arrange a storefront on Bookshop within the United States and the United Kingdom – take a look and see all my suggestions; Bookshop is ready as much as help native unbiased retailers. Hyperlinks to Bookshop and Amazon could generate referral charges.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here